Dennison and Company repurchased some of its common shares on two previous occasions

Intermediate AccountingShareholders' Equity

The textbook question

On two previous occasions, the management of Dennison and Company, Inc. repurchased some of its common shares. Between buyback transactions, the corporation issued common shares under its management incentive plan. Shown below is shareholders’ equity following these share transactions, as reported by two different methods of accounting for reacquired shares.

($ in millions)Method AMethod B
Shareholders’ equity
Paid-in capital:
Preferred stock, $10 par$150$150
Common stock, $1 par200197
Additional paid-in capital1,2041,201
Retained earnings2,9942,979
Less: Treasury stock(21)
Total shareholders’ equity$4,527$4,527

Required:

1. Infer from the presentation which method of accounting for reaquired shares is represented by Method A.
2. Infer from the presentation which method of accounting for reaquired shares is represented by Method B.

Below is the Accuity problem: the same method with different numbers. We solve ours, so work through it and you'll know how to solve yours.

The Accuity problem

Accuity has bought back its own shares twice. In between, it issued new shares to senior managers through its incentive plan. An analyst comparing Accuity with competitors laid out what Accuity's shareholders' equity would look like under each of the two ways a company can account for shares it buys back:

($ in millions)Method AMethod B
Shareholders’ equity
Paid-in capital:
Preferred stock, $12 par$180$180
Common stock, $2 par234240
Additional paid-in capital1,3501,356
Retained earnings3,1463,188
Less: Treasury stock(54)
Total shareholders’ equity$4,910$4,910
  1. Which method for reacquired shares does Method A show? How can you tell?
  2. Which method does Method B show? How can you tell?

An Accuity original. We write our own version of each problem and solve it from scratch, so you learn the method rather than copying an answer.

Video solution

Covers the full step-by-step solution below, start to finish.

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Solved by

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Founder of Accuity

Jake started Accuity while studying accounting at UCF and has worked with hundreds of students in introductory and upper-level accounting classes. Accuity solutions are checked against the textbook before they're published.

Certified Public Accountant (CPA) · B.S.B.A. in Accounting, UCF · M.S. in Accounting, UCF

More about Accuity →

Step-by-step solution

The same steps the video works through, written out.

This problem tests the two permitted ways to account for a company's own reacquired shares — formal retirement of the shares versus holding them as treasury stock — and the rule that decides it: retirement removes the shares' original par and paid-in amounts from the accounts, while the treasury stock (cost) method leaves the original issuance accounts untouched and parks the entire repurchase cost in a single contra-equity account.

Assumption: both columns describe the same repurchase and reissuance transactions, recorded two different ways, which is why total shareholders' equity is identical at $4,910 million.

Requirement 1 — Which method is Method A?

Method A presents the shares as having been retired (formally cancelled).

Three features of the Method A column give it away:

  1. There is no treasury stock line at all. When shares are retired, they go back to authorized-but-unissued status. There is nothing left to report as a contra-equity deduction, so the "Less: Treasury stock" caption simply does not appear.

  2. Common stock is smaller: $234 million versus $240 million. Retiring shares requires removing their par value from the Common Stock account. The par removed is:

    $240 - $234 = $6 million

    At $2 par per share, that is 3 million shares retired: $6 million / $2 per share = 3 million shares.

  3. Additional paid-in capital and retained earnings are both lower. Retirement also removes the APIC that was originally credited on those shares, and when the buyback price exceeds the original issue price, the excess is charged against paid-in capital from retirement (if any) and then against retained earnings:

    APIC removed: $1,356 - $1,350 = $6 million

    Retained earnings charged: $3,188 - $3,146 = $42 million

Only retirement accounting can reduce the par account and retained earnings for a share buyback. The treasury stock method never touches either one.

Requirement 2 — Which method is Method B?

Method B presents the shares as treasury stock, accounted for by the cost method.

The tells run the opposite direction:

  1. The explicit "Less: Treasury stock (54)" line. Under the cost method, the full cost paid to reacquire the shares — $54 million — is debited to a single Treasury Stock account and deducted from total shareholders' equity as a contra account. That line can exist only if the shares are being held, not cancelled.
  2. Common stock still carries the full $240 million of par. The shares are issued but not outstanding, so their $2 par stays in the Common Stock account. Likewise, the $1,356 million of APIC from the original issuances is left alone.
  3. Retained earnings is the full $3,188 million. Under the cost method, buying back shares at any price never reduces retained earnings; the entire cost sits in Treasury Stock instead.

Proving the two columns tie

The $54 million of treasury stock in Method B is exactly the amount Method A stripped out of the three paid-in and earned capital accounts:

AccountMethod BMethod AReduction under retirement
Common stock, $2 par$240$234$6
Additional paid-in capital$1,356$1,350$6
Retained earnings$3,188$3,146$42
Total removed$54

Check: $6 + $6 + $42 = $54 million, the exact balance of the Treasury Stock contra account.

Method A total: $180 + $234 + $1,350 + $3,146 = $4,910 million

Method B total: $180 + $240 + $1,356 + $3,188 - $54 = $4,910 million

Both methods report total shareholders' equity of $4,910 million — the choice of method reshuffles the components of equity but never changes the total.

The per-share detail is consistent with that reading: $54 million cost / 3 million shares = $18 average cost per share reacquired, against an average original issue price of $2 par + ($6 million APIC / 3 million shares = $2) = $4 per share, leaving $18 - $4 = $14 per share, or $14 x 3 million = $42 million, charged to retained earnings under retirement.

Where students go wrong

  • Reading the lower retained earnings in Method A as worse performance. Nothing about earnings differs between the columns; the $42 million gap is the debit to retained earnings required when retired shares are bought back for more than they were originally issued for. Net income and total equity are unaffected by the choice.
  • Looking only for the treasury stock line and stopping there. The par-value difference ($240 versus $234) is the more diagnostic clue, because it is the only thing that proves shares were actually cancelled rather than held — and it is what lets you back into the 3 million shares reacquired.

More Shareholders' Equity problems

Got a different wording of this problem?

Assignments vary by school and semester. Share the version you were given and we'll add it so other students can find this solution.

Studying Shareholders' Equity for a class?

Accuity courses map to your actual syllabus — video lessons, exam-style practice, and walkthroughs for the problems you're assigned.