Ford Motor Co. said it will repurchase $1.8 billion of its shares to reduce dilution

Intermediate AccountingShareholders' Equity

The textbook question

The following excerpt is from an article reported in an online issue of Bloomberg .

(Bloomberg) Ford Motor Co. (F) said it will repurchase $1.8 billion of its shares to reduce dilution from recent stock grants to executives.

The par amount per share for Ford’s common stock is $0.01. Paid-in capital—excess of par is $5.39 per share on average. The market price was $16.

Required:

1. Suppose Ford reacquires 112 million shares through repurchase on the open market at $16 per share. Prepare the appropriate journal entry to record the purchase. Ford considers the shares it buys back to be treasury stock.
2. Suppose Ford considers the shares it buys back to be retired rather than treated as treasury stock. Prepare the appropriate journal entry to record the purchase.
3. What does the company mean by saying that the buyback will serve “to offset dilution from executive compensation?”

Source: Bloomberg

Below is the Accuity problem: the same method with different numbers. We solve ours, so work through it and you'll know how to solve yours.

The Accuity problem

Accuity's board approved a plan to buy back up to $112 million of Accuity's common stock. Over the past few years Accuity has paid its course producers, platform engineers and packet team partly in stock. The board says the buyback is meant to offset the dilution those awards caused.

Accuity's common stock has a par value of $0.0001 per share. Paid-in capital—excess of par averages $11.40 per share. The stock trades at $23.60.

  1. Accuity buys 4.2 million shares on the open market at $23.60 and holds them as treasury stock. Record the purchase.
  2. Instead, Accuity retires the shares it buys. Record the purchase.
  3. What does it mean that the buyback "offsets dilution" from the employee stock awards?

An Accuity original. We write our own version of each problem and solve it from scratch, so you learn the method rather than copying an answer.

Video solution

Covers the full step-by-step solution below, start to finish.

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Solved by

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Founder of Accuity

Jake started Accuity while studying accounting at UCF and has worked with hundreds of students in introductory and upper-level accounting classes. Accuity solutions are checked against the textbook before they're published.

Certified Public Accountant (CPA) · B.S.B.A. in Accounting, UCF · M.S. in Accounting, UCF

More about Accuity →

Step-by-step solution

The same steps the video works through, written out.

This problem tests the two ways a company can account for reacquiring its own shares: holding them as treasury stock (cost method — one debit, no gain or loss) versus retiring them (reverse the original issue price out of the paid-in capital accounts, and plug any shortfall to Retained Earnings). A company can never report a gain or loss, or any income statement effect, from trading in its own stock.

Step 0 — The numbers you need

Shares reacquired: 4,200,000

Cash paid: 4,200,000 x $23.60 = $99,120,000

That sits inside the $112 million the board authorized ($112,000,000 - $99,120,000 = $12,880,000 still available), so no issue with the limit.

Original issue amounts carried on the books for those shares:

  • Common stock (par): 4,200,000 x $0.0001 = $420
  • Paid-in capital—excess of par: 4,200,000 x $11.40 = $47,880,000
  • Combined original issue price: $420 + $47,880,000 = $47,880,420

Requirement 1 — Purchase 4.2 million shares as treasury stock

Under the cost method the entire cash outlay goes into one contra-equity account. Par value and the old paid-in capital are left completely untouched, because the shares are not cancelled — they are issued but not outstanding.

AccountDebitCredit
Treasury stock99,120,000
    Cash99,120,000

Debit Treasury stock $99,120,000 and credit Cash $99,120,000. Total shareholders' equity falls by $99,120,000; no account other than Treasury stock and Cash changes.

Requirement 2 — Retire the shares instead

Retirement cancels the shares, so you remove everything that was recorded when those shares were originally sold, then account for the difference between what was received and what was paid.

Amount paid: $99,120,000
Amount originally received (removed from equity): $47,880,420
Difference: $99,120,000 - $47,880,420 = $51,239,580

Accuity paid more to buy the shares back than it got when it sold them. That excess is not a loss — it is a reduction of equity, debited to Retained Earnings (there is no paid-in capital—share repurchase balance from prior retirements to absorb it).

AccountDebitCredit
Common stock420
Paid-in capital—excess of par47,880,000
Retained earnings51,239,580
    Cash99,120,000

Check that it balances: $420 + $47,880,000 + $51,239,580 = $99,120,000. ✔

Debit Common stock $420, Paid-in capital—excess of par $47,880,000, and Retained earnings $51,239,580; credit Cash $99,120,000.

Notice that total shareholders' equity drops by the same $99,120,000 as in Requirement 1. Treasury versus retirement changes which equity accounts move, not the total.

Requirement 3 — What "offsets dilution" means

When Accuity pays its course producers, engineers and packet team in stock, it issues new shares. Every new share issued means:

  • more shares outstanding, so each existing shareholder owns a smaller fraction of the company, and
  • a larger denominator in earnings per share, so the same net income produces a lower EPS.

That is dilution. Buying 4.2 million shares back and either holding them in treasury or retiring them removes those shares from the outstanding count, pushing the share count — and therefore EPS and each holder's ownership percentage — back toward where it was before the awards were granted.

Two things the buyback does not do:

  1. It does not undo the compensation expense. The fair value of the stock awards was already recorded as expense when the employees earned them; repurchasing shares later is an equity transaction and never touches the income statement.
  2. It is not free. Accuity spent $99,120,000 of real cash to mop up shares it issued as a substitute for cash wages. The dilution is reversed in the share count, but the cost of the compensation has now been paid in cash — the buyback simply moves it from the share count to the balance sheet.

"Offsetting dilution" means using cash to retire roughly the same number of shares the stock-compensation plans created, holding shares outstanding (and EPS) steady — not reversing the compensation expense, which has already run through earnings.

Where students go wrong

  • Recording a "loss on repurchase" of $51,239,580 in Requirement 2. A corporation cannot report income statement gains or losses on its own stock. The excess of the buyback price over the original issue price is debited to Retained Earnings (after any existing paid-in capital—share repurchase is used up).
  • Removing par and paid-in capital in Requirement 1. Under the cost method, treasury shares are still issued, so Common stock of $420 and Paid-in capital—excess of par of $47,880,000 stay exactly where they are; the single debit of $99,120,000 to Treasury stock does all the work. Also watch the tiny par: 4,200,000 x $0.0001 is $420, not $420,000.

More Shareholders' Equity problems

Got a different wording of this problem?

Assignments vary by school and semester. Share the version you were given and we'll add it so other students can find this solution.

Studying Shareholders' Equity for a class?

Accuity courses map to your actual syllabus — video lessons, exam-style practice, and walkthroughs for the problems you're assigned.