Williams Industries redeemable Class A and Class B shares: which should be reported as liabilities?

Intermediate AccountingShareholders' Equity

The textbook question

Williams Industries has outstanding 30 million common shares, 20 million Class A shares, and 20 million Class B shares. Williams has the right but not the obligation to repurchase the Class A shares if a change in ownership of the voting common shares causes J. P. Williams, founder and CEO, to have less than 50% ownership. Williams has the unconditional obligation to repurchase the Class B shares upon the death of J. P. Williams.

Required:

Which, if any, of the shares should be reported in Williams’s balance sheet as liabilities?

Below is the Accuity problem: the same method with different numbers. We solve ours, so work through it and you'll know how to solve yours.

The Accuity problem

Accuity's founder and CEO wants to keep control of the company as it brings in outside investors, so its charter sets up two classes of common stock:

  • Class A: 600 million shares authorized, one vote per share, 24 million outstanding.
  • Class B: 120 million shares authorized, three votes per share, 18 million outstanding — all held by the founder.

Two clauses in the charter deal with buying these shares back:

  • If an ownership change leaves the founder with less than 50% of the voting power, Accuity may buy back the Class A shares, but it doesn't have to.
  • When the founder dies, Accuity must buy back the Class B shares.

Should any of these shares appear in Accuity's balance sheet as liabilities rather than equity? Explain.

An Accuity original. We write our own version of each problem and solve it from scratch, so you learn the method rather than copying an answer.

Video solution

Covers the full step-by-step solution below, start to finish.

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Solved by

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Founder of Accuity

Jake started Accuity while studying accounting at UCF and has worked with hundreds of students in introductory and upper-level accounting classes. Accuity solutions are checked against the textbook before they're published.

Certified Public Accountant (CPA) · B.S.B.A. in Accounting, UCF · M.S. in Accounting, UCF

More about Accuity →

Step-by-step solution

The same steps the video works through, written out.

This is a classification question under the rules for redeemable stock: an instrument that looks like stock is still reported as a liability when the issuer has an unconditional obligation to hand over assets to redeem it. The deciding test is who controls whether the redemption happens — if the company can walk away, it's equity; if redemption is certain to occur and the company can't avoid it, it's a liability.

The three buckets

Redemption featureWho controls itBalance sheet classification
Company may redeem (call option)IssuerPermanent equity
Holder may put the shares back, or redemption triggered by an event outside the issuer's controlHolder / outside eventTemporary ("mezzanine") equity, between liabilities and equity
Company must redeem at a fixed date, or on an event certain to occurNobody — it is unavoidableLiability

Notice that nothing in this test depends on votes per share. The 1-vote/3-vote split and the founder's 54 million votes (18 million x 3) versus the Class A holders' 24 million votes matter for control and EPS presentation, not for whether a share is debt or equity.

Class A — 24 million shares, redeemable at the company's option

The charter says that if the founder's voting power falls below 50%, Accuity may buy back the Class A shares, "but it doesn't have to."

That is a call option held by the issuer, not an obligation. Two things have to happen before any cash moves: (1) an ownership change occurs, and (2) Accuity decides to exercise. Step (2) is entirely within Accuity's control, so there is no unconditional obligation to transfer assets, and the condition in (1) never ripens into one on its own.

Class A shares stay in permanent stockholders' equity.

(Contrast: if the Class A holders could force Accuity to buy them out on an ownership change, the shares would be pulled out of permanent equity and parked in the mezzanine, because the trigger would sit outside the company's control.)

Class B — 18 million shares, mandatory redemption on the founder's death

The charter says Accuity must buy back the Class B shares when the founder dies. Run the test:

  • Is the obligation conditional on something Accuity can avoid? No — the company has no say in the matter.
  • Is the triggering event certain to occur? Yes. Death is certain; only the timing is unknown, and uncertain timing does not make an obligation conditional.

So Accuity has an unconditional obligation to transfer assets (cash) to the founder's estate. These shares are mandatorily redeemable and meet the definition of a liability even though they are legally common stock.

The 18 million Class B shares are reported as a liability, not as equity.

Two consequences that follow from that classification:

  • The liability is measured at the redemption/settlement amount (or fair value, depending on how the redemption price is set), and it is remeasured each period as that amount changes.
  • Any "dividends" paid on Class B shares are interest expense on the income statement, not a reduction of retained earnings. Likewise, the remeasurement each period runs through income as interest cost, not through equity.
  • Class B shares classified as liabilities are excluded from the denominator of basic EPS, since they are not outstanding equity for that purpose.

Practice note: for a company that is private and not an SEC registrant, GAAP indefinitely defers liability classification for mandatorily redeemable shares that are not redeemable on a fixed date for a fixed amount — disclosure is required instead. The general rule above is what this problem is testing.

Summary of the answer

ClassShares outstandingRedemption triggerCan Accuity avoid paying?Reported as
Class A24,000,000Ownership change — company may redeemYes, it is the company's choiceStockholders' equity
Class B18,000,000Founder's death — company must redeemNo, and the event is certainLiability

Only the Class B shares are reported as liabilities. The Class A shares remain in stockholders' equity because redemption is at Accuity's option, while the Class B shares carry an unconditional obligation to redeem upon an event — the founder's death — that is certain to occur.

Where students go wrong

  • Assuming anything labeled "common stock" must be equity. Legal form does not control here; the substance of the redemption obligation does. Mandatorily redeemable common shares are a liability.
  • Treating the uncertain timing of the founder's death as if it made redemption "contingent." The event itself is certain, so the obligation is unconditional — unknown timing affects measurement, not classification. The mirror-image error is flagging Class A as a liability just because a buyback is mentioned; a call option the company may decline creates no obligation at all.
  • Letting the voting rights drive the answer. The 3-votes-per-share feature is about control, not about debt versus equity classification.

More Shareholders' Equity problems

Got a different wording of this problem?

Assignments vary by school and semester. Share the version you were given and we'll add it so other students can find this solution.

Studying Shareholders' Equity for a class?

Accuity courses map to your actual syllabus — video lessons, exam-style practice, and walkthroughs for the problems you're assigned.