Douglas McDonald Company stock dividend with cash in lieu of fractional share rights

Intermediate AccountingShareholders' Equity

The textbook question

Douglas McDonald Company’s balance sheet included the following shareholders’ equity accounts at December 31, 2023:

($ in millions)
Paid-in capital:
Common stock, 900 million shares at $1 par$900
Paid-in capital—excess of par15,800
Retained earnings14,888
Total shareholders’ equity$31,588

On March 16, 2024, a 4% common stock dividend was declared and distributed. The market value of the common stock was $21 per share. Fractional share rights represented 2 million equivalent whole shares. Cash was paid in lieu of the fractional share rights.

Required:

1. What is a fractional share right?
2. Prepare the appropriate entries for the declaration and distribution of the stock dividend.

Below is the Accuity problem: the same method with different numbers. We solve ours, so work through it and you'll know how to solve yours.

The Accuity problem

Accuity decided to pay a stock dividend this year rather than cash. At January 1 its shareholders' equity was:

Shareholders' Equity($ in millions)
Common stock, 750 million shares at $2 par$1,500
Paid-in capital—excess of par18,400
Retained earnings16,275
Total shareholders' equity$36,175

On March 16, Accuity declared and distributed a 4% common stock dividend, when the stock was trading at $24 a share. Many shareholders' holdings didn't divide evenly, leaving them with fractions of a share. Those fractions added up to the equivalent of 3 million whole shares, and Accuity paid cash for them instead of issuing shares.

  1. What is a fractional share right?
  2. Record the declaration and distribution of the stock dividend.

An Accuity original. We write our own version of each problem and solve it from scratch, so you learn the method rather than copying an answer.

Video solution

Covers the full step-by-step solution below, start to finish.

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Solved by

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Founder of Accuity

Jake started Accuity while studying accounting at UCF and has worked with hundreds of students in introductory and upper-level accounting classes. Accuity solutions are checked against the textbook before they're published.

Certified Public Accountant (CPA) · B.S.B.A. in Accounting, UCF · M.S. in Accounting, UCF

More about Accuity →

Step-by-step solution

The same steps the video works through, written out.

This is a small stock dividend (less than 20–25% of shares outstanding), so the dividend is recorded at the fair value of the shares distributable, with retained earnings reduced by the full market value of the equivalent shares. Because fractional interests are settled in cash, the portion of the dividend represented by those fractions leaves the company as cash instead of becoming paid-in capital.

Assumption: the dividend was declared and distributed on the same date (March 16), so a single combined entry is made; if your instructor wants the declaration and distribution split, the declaration credits "Common stock distributable" for $54 and the distribution reclassifies it to "Common stock."

Requirement 1 — What is a fractional share right?

When a stock dividend percentage is applied to a shareholder's holdings, the result usually isn't a whole number of shares. A shareholder owning 150 shares who receives a 4% stock dividend is entitled to 150 x 0.04 = 6 shares exactly, but a shareholder owning 155 shares is entitled to 155 x 0.04 = 6.2 shares — six whole shares plus two-tenths of a share.

A fractional share right is a certificate issued for that leftover fraction. It entitles the holder to a stated fraction of a share. The holder can combine it with other rights (bought from other shareholders, or already held) to assemble a full share, or sell it. Rather than administer these rights, many corporations — Accuity here — simply pay cash equal to the market value of the fractional interests, which is called paying cash in lieu of fractional shares.

A fractional share right represents a claim to less than one whole share arising because a shareholder's holdings don't divide evenly by the stock dividend rate; it can be combined or sold to obtain a whole share, or the company may settle it in cash at market value.

Requirement 2 — Compute the amounts

Step 1: Total share equivalents in the dividend

750 million shares x 4% = 30 million share equivalents

Step 2: Split between shares actually issued and fractions paid in cash

Fractional rights settled in cash = 3 million share equivalents

30 million - 3 million = 27 million whole shares actually issued

Step 3: Charge to retained earnings at fair value (small stock dividend)

30 million shares x $24 market price = $720 million

Step 4: Credit to common stock at par, for shares actually issued only

27 million shares x $2 par = $54 million

Step 5: Cash paid for the fractional share rights, at market value

3 million share equivalents x $24 = $72 million

Step 6: Paid-in capital—excess of par is the plug

$720 million - $54 million - $72 million = $594 million

(Check on the plug: the 27 million shares issued carry $24 - $2 = $22 of excess over par each, and 27 million x $22 = $594 million.)

Requirement 2 — Journal entry (March 16)

AccountDebitCredit
Retained earnings720
    Common stock (27 million x $2 par)54
    Paid-in capital—excess of par594
    Cash (3 million x $24)72

($ in millions)

Debits equal credits: $54 + $594 + $72 = $720.

Debit Retained earnings $720 million; credit Common stock $54 million, Paid-in capital—excess of par $594 million, and Cash $72 million.

Effect on shareholders' equity

Account ($ in millions)BeforeChangeAfter
Common stock, $2 par1,500+541,554
Paid-in capital—excess of par18,400+59418,994
Retained earnings16,275(720)15,555
Total shareholders' equity36,175(72)36,103

A pure stock dividend doesn't change total equity — it only shuffles amounts within it. Total equity falls here by exactly the $72 million of cash paid out for the fractional share rights.

Shares outstanding after the distribution: 750 million + 27 million = 777 million shares.

Where students go wrong

  • Crediting common stock for all 30 million shares. Only 27 million shares were actually issued; the 3 million share equivalents were bought out with cash, so no par value is recorded for them. Crediting 30 million x $2 = $60 million overstates common stock and understates the paid-in capital plug.
  • Charging retained earnings for only the 27 million shares issued. Retained earnings is reduced by the full $720 million fair value of the entire 4% dividend, including the fractions, because the fractional holders received the same $24 of value — just in cash. Likewise, don't record the cash portion at par ($6 million) instead of market value ($72 million).
  • Using par instead of fair value. This is a 4% dividend, well under the 20–25% threshold, so it is measured at the $24 market price, not at the $2 par value.

More Shareholders' Equity problems

Got a different wording of this problem?

Assignments vary by school and semester. Share the version you were given and we'll add it so other students can find this solution.

Studying Shareholders' Equity for a class?

Accuity courses map to your actual syllabus — video lessons, exam-style practice, and walkthroughs for the problems you're assigned.