Miller-Li Corporation changes from treasury stock to retired stock

Intermediate AccountingShareholders' Equity

The textbook question

In keeping with a modernization of corporate statutes in its home state, Miller-Li Corporation decided in 2024 to discontinue accounting for reacquired shares as treasury stock. Instead, shares repurchased will be viewed as having been retired, reassuming the status of unissued shares. As part of the change, treasury shares held were reclassified as retired stock. At December 31, 2023, Miller-Li’s balance sheet reported the following shareholders’ equity:

($ in millions)
Common stock, $1 par$200
Paid-in capital—excess of par800
Retained earnings956
Treasury stock (4 million shares at cost)(25)
Total shareholders’ equity$1,931

Required:

Identify the type of accounting change this decision represents, and prepare the journal entry to effect the reclassification of treasury shares as retired shares.

Below is the Accuity problem: the same method with different numbers. We solve ours, so work through it and you'll know how to solve yours.

The Accuity problem

Accuity's home state rewrote its corporate statutes, and the new law no longer recognizes treasury stock. This year Accuity changed its policy to match. From now on, any share it buys back is retired and goes back to authorized but unissued status. The treasury shares it already held are retired too.

At the start of the year, before the change, Accuity reported:

Shareholders' Equity($ in millions)
Common stock, $2 par$240
Paid-in capital—excess of par920
Retained earnings1,084
Treasury stock (3 million shares, at cost)(33)
Total shareholders' equity$2,211
  1. What kind of accounting change is this?
  2. Record the entry that retires the treasury shares.

An Accuity original. We write our own version of each problem and solve it from scratch, so you learn the method rather than copying an answer.

Video solution

Covers the full step-by-step solution below, start to finish.

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Solved by

Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA

Founder of Accuity

Jake started Accuity while studying accounting at UCF and has worked with hundreds of students in introductory and upper-level accounting classes. Accuity solutions are checked against the textbook before they're published.

Certified Public Accountant (CPA) · B.S.B.A. in Accounting, UCF · M.S. in Accounting, UCF

More about Accuity →

Step-by-step solution

The same steps the video works through, written out.

This problem tests two things: how to classify a shift in the way share repurchases are handled, and how to allocate the cost of retired shares among the equity accounts. The rule for the entry: when shares are retired, you reverse the original issuance amounts (par plus the pro rata share of paid-in capital—excess of par), and any excess of repurchase cost over those amounts is debited to retained earnings (or to paid-in capital—share repurchase if such a credit balance exists).

Requirement 1 — What kind of accounting change is this?

GAAP permits two acceptable ways to account for reacquired shares: hold them as treasury stock, or retire them and return them to authorized-but-unissued status. The choice between the two is not dictated by the nature of the buyback itself — the repurchase transaction is the same economic event either way — but by practical and legal motivations. Accuity changed its policy from one acceptable method to the other.

A switch from one generally accepted accounting method to another generally accepted accounting method for the same kind of transaction is a change in accounting principle.

What makes this particular change mild is its reach. Retiring shares rather than carrying them as treasury stock changes only how the total is divided among the individual shareholders' equity accounts — common stock, paid-in capital—excess of par, and retained earnings. It does not change the total of shareholders' equity, and it does not touch net income in any period, because a company never reports a gain or loss on transactions in its own shares.

This is a change in accounting principle — a change from one acceptable method (treasury stock) to another acceptable method (retirement). Its only effect is on the composition of shareholders' equity; total shareholders' equity and net income are unaffected.

Requirement 2 — Set up the numbers for the retirement

First, how many shares has Accuity issued? Work backward from the common stock balance:

Shares issued = $240 million / $2 par = 120 million shares

Next, the average paid-in capital in excess of par per issued share:

$920 million / 120 million shares = $7.6667 per share

Now apply both to the 3 million shares being retired:

  • Par to remove: 3 million x $2 = $6 million
  • Paid-in capital—excess of par to remove: 3 million x $7.6667 = $23 million (check: $920 x 3/120 = $23 million)
  • Total originally credited on those shares: $6 million + $23 million = $29 million

Compare that to what Accuity paid for them:

Cost of treasury shares = $33 million, or $33 / 3 = $11 per share

$33 million cost − $29 million originally credited = $4 million paid above the original issue price

Because there is no existing paid-in capital—share repurchase credit balance to absorb it, that $4 million is debited to retained earnings.

Requirement 2 — Journal entry

AccountDebitCredit
Common stock6
Paid-in capital—excess of par23
Retained earnings4
    Treasury stock33

(in $ millions)

Entry: debit Common stock $6 million, debit Paid-in capital—excess of par $23 million, debit Retained earnings $4 million, credit Treasury stock $33 million.

Proof — equity after the retirement

Shareholders' Equity($ in millions)
Common stock, $2 par ($240 − $6)$234
Paid-in capital—excess of par ($920 − $23)897
Retained earnings ($1,084 − $4)1,080
Treasury stock ($33 − $33)0
Total shareholders' equity$2,211

Total shareholders' equity is unchanged at $2,211 million — retiring shares only shuffles amounts within equity, since the cash was already spent when the shares were bought. That is the quickest check that the entry is right.

Where students go wrong

  • Removing par only ($6 million) and plugging the entire $27 million remainder to retained earnings. You must also remove the pro rata paid-in capital—excess of par on those specific shares, $920 x 3/120 = $23 million, before any retained earnings debit.
  • Expecting a change in accounting principle to move total shareholders' equity or net income. Here the change only redistributes amounts among the individual equity accounts; the $2,211 million total is the same before and after.
  • Debiting a loss or expense for the $4 million. A company never reports a gain or loss in income on transactions in its own shares; the difference lands in equity.

More Shareholders' Equity problems

Got a different wording of this problem?

Assignments vary by school and semester. Share the version you were given and we'll add it so other students can find this solution.

Studying Shareholders' Equity for a class?

Accuity courses map to your actual syllabus — video lessons, exam-style practice, and walkthroughs for the problems you're assigned.