Neagle Corporation imposes a payback cutoff of 2.5 years: payback vs. NPV
Business FinanceCapital Budgeting
The question
Neagle Corporation imposes a payback cutoff of 2.5 years for its capital investment projects. The company has the following two projects available:
| Year | Project A Cash Flows | Project B Cash Flows |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | -$42,500 | -$120,000 |
| 1 | 28,000 | 52,000 |
| 2 | 26,000 | 49,000 |
| 3 | 6,000 | 25,000 |
| 4 | 5,000 | 45,000 |
a) Using the payback technique, should the company accept either of the projects?
b) If the company has a required rate of return of 12% for capital investments what is the NPV of each of these projects? Should either be accepted? Does this decision agree with the decision made in part (a)? What if the projects are mutually exclusive?
Below is the Accuity problem: the same method with different numbers. We solve ours, so work through it and you'll know how to solve yours.
The Accuity problem
Clover Corp. accepts capital investment projects only if they pay back within 2.5 years. Two projects are available:
| Year | Project X Cash Flows | Project Y Cash Flows |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | (48,000) | (125,000) |
| 1 | 30,000 | 55,000 |
| 2 | 28,000 | 51,000 |
| 3 | 7,000 | 28,000 |
| 4 | 6,000 | 48,000 |
- Under the payback rule, should Clover accept either project?
- With a 13% required rate of return, what is each project's NPV? Should either be accepted, and does that agree with requirement 1? Which project should Clover choose if the two are mutually exclusive?
An Accuity original. We write our own version of each problem and solve it from scratch, so you learn the method rather than copying an answer.
Video solution
Covers the full step-by-step solution below, start to finish.

Solved by
Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA
Founder of Accuity
Jake started Accuity while studying accounting at UCF and has worked with hundreds of students in introductory and upper-level accounting classes. Accuity solutions are checked against the textbook before they're published.
Certified Public Accountant (CPA) · B.S.B.A. in Accounting, UCF · M.S. in Accounting, UCF
More about Accuity →Step-by-step solution
The same steps the video works through, written out.
This problem tests the payback rule against the NPV rule, and shows how payback can reject a project that adds value.
Requirement 1: Payback
Track cumulative cash flow until the cost is recovered.
| Year | X cash flow | X cumulative | Y cash flow | Y cumulative |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | (48,000) | (48,000) | (125,000) | (125,000) |
| 1 | 30,000 | (18,000) | 55,000 | (70,000) |
| 2 | 28,000 | 10,000 | 51,000 | (19,000) |
| 3 | 7,000 | 17,000 | 28,000 | 9,000 |
| 4 | 6,000 | 23,000 | 48,000 | 57,000 |
- Project X:
1 + 18,000 ÷ 28,000 = 1.64 years→ within 2.5 years, accept. - Project Y:
2 + 19,000 ÷ 28,000 = 2.68 years→ longer than 2.5 years, reject.
Answer 1: accept Project X only.
Requirement 2: NPV at 13%
| Year | X PV at 13% | Y PV at 13% |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | 26,548.67 | 48,672.57 |
| 2 | 21,928.11 | 39,940.48 |
| 3 | 4,851.35 | 19,405.40 |
| 4 | 3,679.91 | 29,439.30 |
| PV of inflows | 57,008.04 | 137,457.75 |
| Less cost | (48,000.00) | (125,000.00) |
| NPV | 9,008.04 | 12,457.75 |
HP 10BII+ (X): 48000 [+/-] [CFj], 30000 [CFj], 28000 [CFj], 7000 [CFj], 6000 [CFj], 13 [I/YR], [shift] [NPV] → 9,008.04. Repeat for Y.
Both NPVs are positive, so if the projects are independent, Clover should accept both.
Does it agree with payback? Only for Project X. Payback rejects Project Y, but Y adds $12,457.75 of value. The disagreement comes from Y's large $48,000 inflow in year 4, which arrives after the 2.5-year cutoff. Payback ignores it completely, and it also ignores the time value of money.
If the projects are mutually exclusive, choose the higher NPV: Project Y ($12,457.75 > $9,008.04). That is the opposite of the payback answer.
| Rule | Project X | Project Y |
|---|---|---|
| Payback (2.5-year cutoff) | Accept (1.64 yrs) | Reject (2.68 yrs) |
| NPV, independent | Accept | Accept |
| NPV, mutually exclusive | Choose Y |
Takeaway
Payback is a quick liquidity check, but its cutoff is arbitrary and it ignores cash flows after the cutoff. NPV uses every cash flow and the required return, so it is the rule to follow.
Mistakes to avoid
- Dividing the remaining balance by the wrong year's cash flow. The fraction uses the year in which recovery happens.
- Calling Y unacceptable because it fails payback. A positive NPV means it creates value.
More Capital Budgeting problems
- Lopez Industries projects A and B: MIRR compared with NPVModified internal rate of return for two mutually exclusive projects, compounding inflows at the required return, and a check of whether MIRR agrees with NPV.
- Project requiring construction expenses through year 2: IRR and NPVIRR and NPV for a project with three years of construction outflows before eight years of inflows, using grouped cash flows on the HP 10BII+.
- Consider the following cash flows that switch signs: IRR or NPV at 11%Non-conventional cash flows that change sign several times: computes the IRR, explains why IRR can be unreliable here, and confirms the decision with NPV and MIRR.
- Nonlinear Dynamics, Inc. must decide between two game projects: EAAChooses between two mutually exclusive projects with different lives and different risk-adjusted rates by converting each NPV into an equivalent annual annuity.
- Suppose your firm is choosing between two exclusive projects: PI vs. NPVRanks two mutually exclusive projects of different size by profitability index and by NPV, then explains why the ratio and the dollar measure disagree.
- Franchise investment in Lazy Moon Pizza: 15-year NPV and IRRFranchise investment with land, building, equipment, working capital and a franchise fee: annual cash flow from monthly figures, terminal value of land and building, NPV and IRR.
Got a different wording of this problem?
Assignments vary by school and semester. Share the version you were given and we'll add it so other students can find this solution.
Studying Capital Budgeting for a class?
Accuity courses map to your actual syllabus — video lessons, exam-style practice, and walkthroughs for the problems you're assigned.