Suppose your firm is choosing between two exclusive projects: PI vs. NPV
Business FinanceCapital Budgeting
The question
Suppose your firm is trying to choose between the two mutually exclusive projects below:
| Year | Project X Cash Flows | Project Y Cash Flows |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | -$45,000 | -$10,000 |
| 1 | 20,000 | 5,000 |
| 2 | 20,000 | 5,000 |
| 3 | 20,000 | 5,000 |
a) If the required return is 12 percent and you apply the profitability index decision rule, which project should your firm accept?
b) If you apply the NPV decision rule, which project should you take?
c) Are your answers to (a) and (b) the same? If not, explain why they are different.
Below is the Accuity problem: the same method with different numbers. We solve ours, so work through it and you'll know how to solve yours.
The Accuity problem
SolarTech Inc. must choose between two mutually exclusive projects:
| Year | Project A Cash Flows | Project B Cash Flows |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | (70,000) | (20,000) |
| 1 | 40,000 | 12,000 |
| 2 | 40,000 | 12,000 |
| 3 | 40,000 | 12,000 |
- With a 13% required return, which project should SolarTech accept under the profitability index rule?
- Which project should it accept under the NPV rule?
- Do the two rules give the same answer? If not, explain why.
An Accuity original. We write our own version of each problem and solve it from scratch, so you learn the method rather than copying an answer.
Video solution
Covers the full step-by-step solution below, start to finish.

Solved by
Jake Glidden, CPA, MSA
Founder of Accuity
Jake started Accuity while studying accounting at UCF and has worked with hundreds of students in introductory and upper-level accounting classes. Accuity solutions are checked against the textbook before they're published.
Certified Public Accountant (CPA) · B.S.B.A. in Accounting, UCF · M.S. in Accounting, UCF
More about Accuity →Step-by-step solution
The same steps the video works through, written out.
This problem tests the profitability index (PI) and NPV rules, and why they can disagree for mutually exclusive projects of different size.
Setup
Both projects pay a level amount for 3 years, so each set of inflows is an annuity. At 13%:
PVIFA(13%, 3) = [1 − (1.13)^−3] ÷ 0.13 = 2.36115
HP 10BII+ (A): 1 [shift] [P/YR], 3 [N], 13 [I/YR], 40000 [PMT], 0 [FV], [PV] → −94,446.10. Repeat with 12000 [PMT] for B.
| Project A | Project B | |
|---|---|---|
| Annual inflow | $40,000 | $12,000 |
| PV of inflows (× 2.36115) | $94,446.10 | $28,333.83 |
| Initial cost | $70,000 | $20,000 |
Requirement 1: Profitability index rule
PI = PV of inflows ÷ cost
- Project A:
$94,446.10 ÷ $70,000 = 1.349 - Project B:
$28,333.83 ÷ $20,000 = 1.417
Answer 1: the PI rule picks Project B (1.417 > 1.349).
Requirement 2: NPV rule
NPV = PV of inflows − cost
- Project A:
$94,446.10 − $70,000 = $24,446.10 - Project B:
$28,333.83 − $20,000 = $8,333.83
Answer 2: the NPV rule picks Project A ($24,446.10 > $8,333.83).
Requirement 3: Why the answers differ
| Project A | Project B | |
|---|---|---|
| PI | 1.349 | 1.417 |
| NPV | $24,446.10 | $8,333.83 |
Answer 3: No, the rules disagree because of a size disparity. Project A costs 3.5 times as much as Project B. PI is a ratio, so it measures value created per dollar and ignores how many dollars are invested. Project B earns slightly more per dollar, but on a far smaller base. NPV measures the total dollars of value added.
You can see that the extra money in Project A is well spent with an incremental PI:
($94,446.10 − $28,333.83) ÷ ($70,000 − $20,000) = $66,112.27 ÷ $50,000 = 1.322
The extra $50,000 invested in A returns $1.32 of present value per dollar, so it adds value.
Decision
When projects are mutually exclusive and capital is not rationed, the goal is to maximize shareholder wealth, which NPV measures directly. SolarTech should choose Project A. PI is most useful when capital is limited and you must rank many independent projects by value per dollar.
Mistakes to avoid
- Concluding that a higher PI means a better project when the projects differ in size.
- Computing PI as NPV ÷ cost (that gives 0.349 and 0.417, which is PI − 1).
- Using a different rate for each project. Both are discounted at 13%.
More Capital Budgeting problems
- Lopez Industries projects A and B: MIRR compared with NPVModified internal rate of return for two mutually exclusive projects, compounding inflows at the required return, and a check of whether MIRR agrees with NPV.
- Neagle Corporation imposes a payback cutoff of 2.5 years: payback vs. NPVApplies a payback cutoff to two projects, then computes each project's NPV and shows where payback and NPV disagree, including the mutually exclusive choice.
- Project requiring construction expenses through year 2: IRR and NPVIRR and NPV for a project with three years of construction outflows before eight years of inflows, using grouped cash flows on the HP 10BII+.
- Consider the following cash flows that switch signs: IRR or NPV at 11%Non-conventional cash flows that change sign several times: computes the IRR, explains why IRR can be unreliable here, and confirms the decision with NPV and MIRR.
- Nonlinear Dynamics, Inc. must decide between two game projects: EAAChooses between two mutually exclusive projects with different lives and different risk-adjusted rates by converting each NPV into an equivalent annual annuity.
- Franchise investment in Lazy Moon Pizza: 15-year NPV and IRRFranchise investment with land, building, equipment, working capital and a franchise fee: annual cash flow from monthly figures, terminal value of land and building, NPV and IRR.
Got a different wording of this problem?
Assignments vary by school and semester. Share the version you were given and we'll add it so other students can find this solution.
Studying Capital Budgeting for a class?
Accuity courses map to your actual syllabus — video lessons, exam-style practice, and walkthroughs for the problems you're assigned.